Hi, Shrewd!        Login  
Shrewd'm.com 
A merry & shrewd investing community
Best Of PoliticsBest OfAll BoardsThe Shrewd’m WeeklyLearn to InvestHow to Become Shrewd
Search
Shrewd'm.com Merry shrewd investors
Search
Best Of PoliticsBest OfAll BoardsThe Shrewd’m WeeklyLearn to InvestHow to Become Shrewd


The week's question
In March 2025, in the thread "Re: OT, out", Umm asked the members: "Do you think it is because America is made up of magical soil that makes businesses based in America magically profitable?" This week it is put to everyone again. The button below opens the small thread re-asking it - read what others have said so far, then give your own answer as an ordinary reply.
Answer this questionContinue to Shrewd'mThis note won't appear again
Halls of Shrewd'm / US Policy
Unthreaded | Threaded | Whole Thread (26) |
Author: Lapsody ⎊✹  😊 😞
Number: of 86289 
Subject: Re: The true meaning of the "right to bear arms&q
Date: 07/18/23 10:27 PM
Post New | Post Reply | Report Post | Recommend It!
No. of Recommendations: 1
Therefore, the federal government can't prohibit individual citizens from owning firearms.

We end up with individual rights to keep and bear that are unconnected to the militia because the prefatory clause has no effect on the operative clause of to keep and to bear. The Constitution outlined the Militia:

Section 8.
Clause 15. The Congress shall have Power * * * To provide for calling forth the Militia to execute the Laws of the Union, suppress Insurrections and repel Invasions.

Clause 16. The Congress shall have Power * * * To provide for organizing, arming, and disciplining, the Militia, and for governing such Part of them as may be employed in the Service of the United States, reserving to the States respectively, the Appointment of the Officers, and the Authority of training the Militia according to the discipline prescribed by Congress.

So this is the Constitutional militia. And under Ch 12 of the Federal Code it is all able bodied men between 17 and 45. Modernly, the organized militia in the code is the National Guard, and the unorganized militia is the pool of able bodied men (17-45) that both the Federal Government and the State can draft from and enlist. There are a few bodies that might be considered militia - DeSantis' State Guard if he turns it military (looks like it), but there are no private or self appointed militia. The States had dealt with Shays rebellion and kept that power to themselves and the Fed.

So the individual right is based mostly on self defense. The easier way to deal with the second amendment is to alter it from a right that seems to be sacrosanct to one that can be limited. Trying to repeal or amend it is too hard, but we can interpret it so it can be limited.
Post New | Post Reply | Report Post | Recommend It!
Print the post
Members reply directly to Lapsody here — and replies get answered. Reading is free; so is joining the conversation. Join Shrewd'm »
This community has written 86,214 posts about US Policy. The article-length ones it recommended most:
It's going to get worse · 33 recs · 2025
G’day Donny · 30 recs · 2026
Old Related Story · 28 recs · 2026
HCR is a national treasure · 27 recs · 2025
Fascism in America · 27 recs · 2025
Unthreaded | Threaded | Whole Thread (26) |


Announcements
US Policy FAQ
Contact Shrewd'm
Contact the developer of these message boards.

Best Of Politics | Best Of | Favourites & Replies | All Boards | Followed Shrewds | Open Questions | Moving a community