No. of Recommendations: 4
Sounds like a straw man argument against communism. Except that neither communists nor any other model of government ever proposed that the government should or could provide for all the needs of all the people. In practice, the government must employ a lot of people if it is to provide anything. And if it wants to provide "everything" then it must ultimately employ everyone.
In contrast to Calhoun who tried to play god to the rats, providing them with everything, in human society god provides nothing and humans are left to provide for themselves.
