Post #55846 by g0177325 on the US Policy board

Halls of Shrewd'm / US Policy ❤

Unthreaded | Threaded | Whole Thread (2)

Post Reply | Report Post | Recommend It!

No. of Recommendations: 7

Every community that values open dialogue eventually encounters trolls. A troll is defined by intent: to disrupt, provoke, and derail discussion rather than engage with ideas in good faith. The arsenal of troll tactics follows predictable patterns, and when examined carefully, twenty-nine distinct maneuvers appear repeatedly across online spaces.

Trolls deploy false equivalence to flatten serious issues into meaningless comparisons and employ diversion to shift focus away from evidence. They construct straw man arguments that distort original positions and wield sarcasm to belittle rather than enlighten. They nitpick grammar or wording to dodge the core argument, feign confusion to stall progress, and move the goalposts once their questions receive answers. They thrive on demanding endless “gotcha” questions that exhaust, bombard discussions with irrelevant questions designed to sideline inconvenient facts, project their own behaviors onto opponents, cherry-pick fragments out of context, misquote sources to suit their narrative, recycle debunked claims as though they were fresh, and abruptly shift subjects entirely when pressed.

Glass Empires By W. Lawrence is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

Subscribe
The repertoire extends further. Trolls cite irrelevant statistics to create noise, invoke conspiracy theories when logic fails, posture as subject matter experts without genuine knowledge, and substitute clichés for authentic reasoning. They fabricate false balance with claims that “both sides do this,” adopt victimhood when challenged, and refuse to answer direct questions that might reveal their positions. They target tone instead of substance, unleash insults to provoke emotion, and flood discussion threads with repetitive rants. They adopt fake politeness before suddenly turning hostile, storm away with insults only to return later, and ignore context by obsessing over minutiae. They dismiss sources without meaningful engagement, resort to mockery as a substitute for argument, and coordinate with allies to isolate their chosen targets.

These maneuvers serve domination, not persuasion. Political discourse reveals how trolling often connects to toxic masculinity, with exaggerated aggression replacing reasoned strength. Online anonymity intensifies this performance, encouraging displays that mirror broader bullying cultures. At the psychological core lies narcissism: an inflated sense of superiority, a constant hunger for validation, and an inability to admit error. Trolls lash out with rage when challenged, double down on false claims, and project their own inadequacies onto others. Trolling becomes an addictive performance, a way to feed fragile egos by silencing dissent.

Philosophical traditions warned against wasting energy on those who argue only to assert dominance. Media and communication scholars demonstrate how trolling corrodes trust by transforming discussion into spectacle. Effective responses depend on clarity, boundaries, and solidarity. Clarity matters because trolls exploit ambiguity, and naming their tactics strips them of power. Boundaries matter because trolls depend on attention, and withholding energy deprives them of oxygen. Solidarity matters because trolls attempt to isolate their targets, and collective responses from good-faith participants neutralize their influence.

The presence of trolls often signals that meaningful work strikes nerves. Trolls surface when lies face threats and abuses face exposure. Recognizing and naming their twenty-nine maneuvers makes manipulation visible and strips trolls of their ability to dictate the terms of debate. Trolls demand attention to survive, but refusing their bait and maintaining focus on content preserves the foundation of authentic democratic dialogue.

https://wendy664.substack.com/p/exposed-the-29-mov...

Print the post

Post Reply | Report Post | Recommend It!

No. of Recommendations: 4

And yet, the trolls continue to be fed, even here. ☹️

Print the post

Post New

Unthreaded | Threaded | Whole Thread (2)

Prev | Next

Announcements

US Policy FAQ

Contact Shrewd'm
Contact the developer of these message boards.