Hi, Shrewd!        Login  
Shrewd'm.com 
A merry & shrewd investing community
Best Of MIBest OfAll BoardsThe Shrewd’m WeeklyLearn to InvestHow to Become Shrewd
Search
Shrewd'm.com Merry shrewd investors
Search
Best Of MIBest OfAll BoardsThe Shrewd’m WeeklyLearn to InvestHow to Become Shrewd


The week's question
In March 2025, in the thread "Re: OT, out", Umm asked the members: "Do you think it is because America is made up of magical soil that makes businesses based in America magically profitable?" This week it is put to everyone again. The button below opens the small thread re-asking it - read what others have said so far, then give your own answer as an ordinary reply.
Answer this questionContinue to Shrewd'mThis note won't appear again
Investment Strategies / Mechanical Investing
Unthreaded | Threaded | Whole Thread (52) |
Author: zeelotes ✹🐝🐝  😊 😞
Number: of 6243 
Subject: Re: What constitutes success?
Date: 04/16/24 7:36 PM
Post New | Post Reply | Report Post | Recommend It!
No. of Recommendations: 6
Since there is certainly not much interest in such things - like avoiding bear markets - as in the past, let me wrap up my comments with a study based on following the inflation warning I mentioned today. Here are all the MI Valueline screens returns over this time period.

MI Screen             CAGR     GSD     Sharpe  DDD3    BBW    % Winning  Drawdown
Net-Nets_Grahamified -72.93% 141.07 -1.06 63.34% -1.27 36% -72.10%
Dilution_s -69.54% 64.65 -2.26 59.36% -1.29 36% -67.32%
The_Mirror_s -62.38% 81.24 -1.46 52.96% -1.29 50% -64.32%
Steady_Growth -57.95% 93.3 -1.25 51.28% -1.25 29% -62.75%
Up_5% -54.30% 71.83 -1.27 46.85% -1.26 29% -60.61%
BETA -55.51% 61.05 -1.55 47.33% -1.28 21% -52.92%
PLOWBKLD -49.89% 37.07 -2.2 42.33% -1.3 43% -52.24%
78RPM -43.95% 51.77 -1.26 37.95% -1.27 21% -51.33%
Microcap_Momentum -49.46% 45.49 -1.67 41.28% -1.3 36% -49.50%
Quality_Earnings -47.26% 40.88 -1.84 41.00% -1.28 14% -49.13%
RS13WK -46.13% 37.51 -1.92 38.92% -1.3 29% -44.50%
EG5_AT -41.12% 37.14 -1.64 35.13% -1.29 36% -42.67%
RS1WK -43.40% 45.04 -1.45 36.76% -1.28 43% -42.12%
Melange -39.81% 41.16 -1.46 34.86% -1.26 21% -41.45%
PIH4 -38.75% 43.86 -1.29 33.72% -1.27 43% -41.17%
RSWEPS -35.04% 53.46 -0.87 30.70% -1.24 50% -40.82%
TTI -33.32% 39.02 -1.14 29.98% -1.21 29% -40.77%
RSEP -40.43% 34.15 -1.73 34.92% -1.27 29% -40.56%
PLOW_PE2 -37.90% 34.74 -1.6 33.00% -1.25 50% -40.46%
RS13WKT12 -41.48% 45.95 -1.3 35.63% -1.27 36% -40.44%
RS4WK -39.97% 41.21 -1.42 34.65% -1.27 29% -39.95%
Advanced -39.34% 37.36 -1.57 33.26% -1.3 29% -39.84%
GAR4 -39.66% 42.32 -1.35 34.02% -1.29 29% -39.57%
ERS26 -39.09% 34.5 -1.63 34.11% -1.27 21% -39.49%
CANSLIM-26 -35.38% 41.75 -1.16 30.94% -1.26 21% -39.40%
OVER_RS -40.16% 32.79 -1.78 34.31% -1.28 29% -39.30%
RS2020 -38.49% 39.95 -1.44 33.30% -1.27 43% -39.15%
SOS_A -37.91% 38.67 -1.48 32.39% -1.27 36% -38.99%
Turnarounds -35.02% 37.5 -1.36 30.88% -1.25 21% -38.98%
ERS13 -38.93% 31.19 -1.86 33.38% -1.28 36% -38.77%
SOSBM_E -26.43% 52.02 -0.68 23.98% -1.16 43% -38.65%
POI -19.59% 50.5 -0.45 20.29% -1.07 50% -38.59%
Overlap_4/13 -38.41% 34.31 -1.61 33.06% -1.28 14% -38.52%
SPARK -32.54% 40.91 -1.16 28.60% -1.25 50% -38.38%
POG -20.02% 46.72 -0.54 20.24% -1.08 50% -38.37%
TPEG13 -33.37% 41.51 -1.11 29.82% -1.22 29% -38.34%
GAR4CFS -38.93% 39.11 -1.46 33.34% -1.29 29% -37.90%
RS4WKT12 -35.72% 42.85 -1.21 31.06% -1.27 43% -37.69%
LPS1+2_RSW -35.73% 29.79 -1.7 30.88% -1.27 43% -37.66%
CAPRS -29.68% 39.05 -1.04 27.00% -1.2 36% -36.85%
SPARKRSW -30.61% 46.53 -0.88 27.43% -1.23 36% -36.69%
TK1_R52 -27.16% 43 -0.79 24.94% -1.19 36% -36.69%
PLOW_PE2MOD -32.39% 40.57 -1.13 28.95% -1.21 29% -36.67%
SOS_D -34.54% 44.29 -1.11 30.12% -1.24 43% -36.30%
RSW -36.17% 34.58 -1.49 31.28% -1.27 29% -36.25%
PST_5/10 -29.15% 44.74 -0.88 26.18% -1.21 43% -36.15%
SOS_F -35.38% 37.47 -1.38 30.33% -1.27 43% -36.02%
SOS_Annual -25.62% 38.5 -0.89 23.59% -1.16 43% -35.93%
Shrinkage -33.59% 33.44 -1.43 29.12% -1.26 43% -35.74%
IN_RS26 -33.46% 33.14 -1.41 29.40% -1.25 36% -35.68%
LLTD -30.70% 37.78 -1.14 26.95% -1.25 21% -35.55%
Bob -28.43% 43.17 -0.81 25.29% -1.23 36% -35.43%
LOWPE_ZLTDA -34.85% 42.09 -1.15 30.07% -1.28 29% -35.18%
FOG_BDF -21.00% 46.27 -0.6 20.49% -1.12 57% -35.05%
KEY100 -26.24% 31.08 -1.16 24.14% -1.19 36% -35.01%
Value_EG -28.62% 41 -0.97 25.90% -1.21 50% -34.95%
Screamers -22.75% 37.78 -0.78 22.10% -1.13 43% -34.77%
REIT -32.85% 32.48 -1.42 28.66% -1.24 36% -34.61%
SOS_Plow_RS -35.56% 32.74 -1.54 30.43% -1.27 29% -34.51%
PIH_Naked -26.78% 50.2 -0.64 24.58% -1.19 21% -34.43%
PEG-NT -18.32% 49.08 -0.42 18.78% -1.06 43% -34.33%
HIGH_CASH -26.48% 36.66 -0.97 24.63% -1.18 36% -34.11%
TA_A -30.54% 34.32 -1.27 26.97% -1.24 43% -34.10%
RSPEG1 -32.31% 31.18 -1.4 28.57% -1.24 29% -34.01%
ROEPLOW -33.49% 33.32 -1.55 29.32% -1.24 43% -33.91%
LPSAD -21.05% 30.06 -0.96 20.09% -1.15 50% -33.74%
BLITZ -31.35% 27.22 -1.59 27.33% -1.25 21% -33.73%
PL_LD_NRS -32.06% 29.43 -1.51 28.11% -1.26 14% -33.43%
TREPPE_E -28.71% 31.76 -1.24 25.54% -1.22 36% -33.18%
RSCAP -22.93% 39.45 -0.74 21.83% -1.15 50% -33.04%
ZLTD -31.94% 37.56 -1.16 27.78% -1.27 21% -32.78%
SOS_BMOD -31.77% 41.14 -1.08 27.76% -1.23 36% -32.77%
PEG13 -33.07% 43.03 -1.02 28.84% -1.23 50% -32.67%
GARPEG -30.17% 41 -0.99 26.69% -1.21 50% -32.57%
SOS_Ancer -27.92% 37.96 -1 25.04% -1.21 50% -32.49%
SOS_Elan_v2001 -26.53% 40.99 -0.9 24.06% -1.19 36% -32.33%
TREPPE -25.24% 35.38 -0.93 23.01% -1.19 43% -32.19%
LPE_YLD -28.06% 33.1 -1.16 25.49% -1.22 29% -32.15%
PEG-Minimalist -11.28% 35.79 -0.36 13.81% -0.88 43% -32.09%
RS26WKT12 -20.14% 46.29 -0.54 19.77% -1.07 43% -31.92%
SOS_B -28.19% 42.24 -0.92 25.12% -1.2 50% -31.80%
AssRS13 -31.95% 32.73 -1.37 28.17% -1.24 29% -31.74%
P/SLove_You -11.94% 33.49 -0.43 13.76% -0.92 43% -31.71%
Incoming_Cash -24.50% 34.75 -1.09 22.81% -1.19 29% -31.66%
HIGHCASHFLOW -28.54% 27.79 -1.44 25.23% -1.25 36% -31.42%
RS52WKT12 -17.25% 49.25 -0.44 17.48% -1.05 50% -31.41%
RSPS -28.50% 36.52 -1.06 25.42% -1.22 50% -31.20%
SOS_Elan_v2002 -23.99% 42.47 -0.76 22.22% -1.14 50% -30.99%
OVER_PEG -24.80% 44.23 -0.76 22.76% -1.17 57% -30.96%
SOS_E -21.55% 37.36 -0.77 20.24% -1.14 43% -30.82%
RS26WK -28.80% 38.61 -0.98 25.55% -1.22 43% -30.67%
CAPLOWEG -22.09% 31.37 -0.94 20.93% -1.16 43% -30.46%
HI_INC_CSH -25.79% 36.1 -1.04 23.50% -1.21 43% -30.15%
GAR_EG5 -26.35% 29.27 -1.21 23.67% -1.21 29% -30.10%
SOS_C -24.52% 43.05 -0.76 22.41% -1.18 50% -30.06%
ROC_RS26WK -27.85% 25.13 -1.51 24.81% -1.23 36% -30.01%
S&P_Peg 63.09% 59.81 1.11 1.08% 28.53 64% -29.88%
EG5PE -23.02% 36.12 -0.85 21.21% -1.17 29% -29.72%
LOWPE 18.08% 59.61 0.41 1.70% 8.73 64% -29.66%
RS52WK -26.00% 37.66 -0.92 23.56% -1.21 43% -29.29%
OPTION_A -19.79% 39.58 -0.65 18.79% -1.13 50% -29.28%
PEGRSW -20.42% 44.72 -0.61 19.37% -1.13 50% -29.21%
FCF-26 -19.23% 33.66 -0.8 19.01% -1.12 50% -29.16%
PLOWRSW -25.92% 27.5 -1.3 23.26% -1.21 43% -29.03%
GS_Mungo -23.41% 24.67 -1.28 21.78% -1.19 29% -28.47%
GS_Mungo_Voom -23.41% 24.67 -1.28 21.78% -1.19 29% -28.47%
EGPLOW_PE -23.87% 29.74 -1.05 21.81% -1.19 36% -28.41%
LowPEsafe 0.75% 54.99 0.04 4.87% 0.16 71% -28.29%
REV -21.85% 37.15 -0.77 20.26% -1.15 21% -28.28%
EGPLOW_PE_E -25.41% 29.51 -1.14 22.90% -1.2 36% -28.23%
REP -22.79% 32.67 -0.89 21.05% -1.17 36% -28.22%
RSPEGOL -26.31% 35.41 -0.97 23.48% -1.21 43% -28.11%
Small_Value -16.33% 33.61 -0.58 16.60% -1.06 43% -27.69%
LPSB -17.56% 26.75 -0.87 17.28% -1.11 36% -27.68%
H52EgPSlta -20.70% 23.33 -1.14 19.36% -1.17 36% -27.65%
ROIC -22.33% 25.45 -1.19 20.54% -1.19 50% -27.57%
SLS_RS13 -26.16% 28.26 -1.27 23.11% -1.22 36% -27.56%
LPS1+2_R26 -22.27% 28.23 -1.05 20.40% -1.19 36% -27.49%
Olap_RS52keyeps -25.69% 32.62 -1.05 23.17% -1.21 36% -27.42%
R13_EG_E -19.03% 28.04 -1.02 18.39% -1.11 36% -27.39%
PLOWEG5_RS631 -24.09% 30.15 -1.09 22.19% -1.19 43% -27.32%
LowPS+ 1.69% 45.8 0.15 3.88% 0.38 50% -27.26%
PEG -12.97% 44.7 -0.33 14.25% -0.94 57% -27.02%
KEYEPS -25.28% 26.72 -1.27 22.76% -1.21 29% -26.98%
KEYSTONE -25.28% 26.72 -1.27 22.76% -1.21 29% -26.98%
EG5_PEG -19.09% 37.56 -0.65 18.22% -1.12 29% -26.94%
FOG_MI -26.62% 32.36 -1.1 23.41% -1.22 36% -26.94%
PEBsize -19.38% 37.76 -0.66 18.55% -1.12 36% -26.93%
PLOW26WK -22.32% 25.66 -1.17 20.46% -1.18 29% -26.93%
LOWPB -14.84% 29.32 -0.76 15.26% -1.06 50% -26.82%
Negative_FCF_s -26.70% 29.03 -1.21 23.47% -1.22 36% -26.59%
SOS_G -17.11% 43.66 -0.49 17.08% -1.06 50% -26.58%
DIVIDEND_GROWTH -25.82% 29.28 -1.21 22.90% -1.23 29% -26.52%
HIPRICE -10.44% 35.27 -0.36 12.38% -0.89 50% -26.49%
R13_EG -15.63% 29.44 -0.81 15.90% -1.05 43% -26.43%
HBSP -12.55% 28.99 -0.58 13.85% -0.98 57% -26.32%
RSPEG2 -23.28% 34.65 -0.86 21.28% -1.17 43% -26.32%
RSEG-rgonsal -19.25% 28.81 -1.01 18.44% -1.12 36% -26.17%
KEYCLQ -22.52% 26.48 -1.12 20.69% -1.18 29% -26.01%
KEYRSW -23.05% 27.06 -1.14 21.17% -1.18 36% -26.00%
PEGFF -2.70% 44.99 -0.05 6.68% -0.4 50% -25.87%
EGRSW -16.90% 45.75 -0.47 16.86% -1.07 50% -25.75%
SOS_GJ -20.60% 36.5 -0.74 19.32% -1.14 36% -25.68%
H52EgPS -18.33% 23.01 -1.02 17.53% -1.14 36% -25.44%
R13_EG2 -14.98% 29.57 -0.75 15.38% -1.04 43% -25.39%
EG -7.71% 44.28 -0.18 10.38% -0.73 57% -25.25%
TK2_R52 -15.23% 33.72 -0.52 15.76% -1.05 36% -25.21%
SOS_Elan_v2000 -15.42% 38.27 -0.54 15.90% -1.03 64% -25.19%
SAFETY_HICCUP -21.67% 24.11 -1.23 20.26% -1.18 29% -25.06%
Fundamentals -0.40% 38.57 0.03 5.38% -0.08 57% -24.58%
PLOWBVS -15.89% 29.14 -0.76 15.88% -1.1 36% -24.54%
PLOWPBV -19.97% 27.92 -1.12 18.88% -1.17 43% -24.54%
SomeMoJoeSafe -9.18% 25.09 -0.51 11.08% -0.88 57% -24.44%
SOS_KJ -21.75% 37.47 -0.73 20.32% -1.15 36% -24.35%
LOWPSR -22.54% 24.21 -1.3 20.27% -1.2 50% -24.30%
PLOW_PE -15.95% 31.59 -0.69 16.10% -1.08 36% -24.28%
EG_PELA -14.84% 37.12 -0.51 15.29% -1.04 43% -24.27%
Olap_RS52keystone -22.32% 31.4 -0.93 20.53% -1.18 36% -24.23%
High_Relative_Value -10.82% 18.88 -0.9 12.34% -0.94 50% -24.18%
GSX -18.95% 24.21 -1.08 17.67% -1.16 36% -23.99%
Value_at_the_Top -14.05% 28.55 -0.61 14.87% -1.04 57% -23.84%
EGPR_PE -14.97% 37.32 -0.5 15.28% -1.04 29% -23.83%
YEYPayout 6.72% 30.98 0.19 1.46% 3.75 64% -23.70%
DALY 11.88% 44.71 0.33 0.94% 7.95 57% -23.65%
SomeMoSafe -2.16% 26.15 -0.19 6.27% -0.36 57% -23.65%
PIH_CSO_safe -18.26% 25.22 -0.95 17.76% -1.13 36% -23.64%
YldDiv -9.32% 26.44 -0.5 11.44% -0.88 50% -23.58%
PIH_CSO_simple -18.05% 25.28 -0.93 17.59% -1.13 36% -23.46%
PLOWLD_NRS -10.97% 37.16 -0.35 12.66% -0.92 43% -23.45%
YLDEARNYEAR2 32.32% 40.03 0.79 0.88% 24.56 64% -23.31%
3PT_Value_SmallCap -17.33% 29.71 -0.75 16.61% -1.11 43% -23.23%
SOS_K -17.08% 37.17 -0.57 16.89% -1.08 43% -23.13%
SLS_RS26 -18.66% 24.2 -1.05 17.76% -1.13 29% -22.91%
JLC_DIV 26.50% 27.54 0.94 1.48% 15.1 71% -22.88%
ARS -10.90% 29.19 -0.49 12.56% -0.95 57% -22.82%
Tvalue -10.97% 37.27 -0.35 12.29% -0.95 50% -22.17%
PIH_MCP -16.84% 24.79 -0.9 16.58% -1.1 36% -21.84%
YLDYEAR 24.14% 33.21 0.74 0.97% 18.21 71% -21.65%
LPCF -4.73% 34.97 -0.23 8.01% -0.6 50% -21.48%
GSX2 -14.85% 26.77 -0.7 14.76% -1.07 50% -21.37%
Fried_500 2.95% 22.94 0.05 2.64% 1.08 43% -21.17%
NoMo -0.10% 27.74 -0.08 4.67% -0.02 57% -20.77%
CDPD -10.31% 27.59 -0.48 11.72% -0.95 50% -20.75%
NoMoSafe -15.56% 28.23 -0.76 15.59% -1.09 50% -20.61%
YIELD4 -1.77% 26.14 -0.16 5.82% -0.31 50% -20.55%
SomeMo -0.54% 27.69 -0.1 4.90% -0.11 57% -20.26%
H52EarnPS -7.04% 24.89 -0.38 9.37% -0.79 43% -20.17%
SomeMoC -1.78% 28.42 -0.14 5.75% -0.32 57% -20.17%
HI_DIV 16.99% 26.98 0.63 1.35% 11.7 64% -20.01%
COREVALU -14.78% 22.94 -0.89 14.74% -1.08 36% -20.00%
Up5X3 -17.36% 20.62 -1.2 16.49% -1.16 43% -19.88%
RS-100 3.08% 36.02 0.17 1.99% 1.22 50% -19.27%
HIYIELD 6.09% 19.66 0.13 1.26% 4.3 57% -18.79%
LOWDV -8.60% 28.04 -0.41 10.49% -0.88 50% -18.27%
ValueRatio 19.08% 29.54 0.61 0.91% 15.08 71% -18.13%
3pt_Relative_Value -8.84% 22.42 -0.61 10.44% -0.91 43% -17.87%
YLDEARNYEAR 28.08% 30.48 0.85 0.74% 30.19 71% -17.29%
BI -13.47% 23.82 -0.8 13.48% -1.06 43% -17.05%
3PT_SCV_pst_slta -5.06% 23.51 -0.31 7.45% -0.69 36% -17.01%
3PT_SCV_pst -4.10% 23.26 -0.25 6.68% -0.61 36% -16.68%
Gentle_Screamers -9.26% 30.6 -0.38 10.56% -0.91 36% -16.61%
SAFETY_BOUNCE 1.97% 19.24 0 3.13% 0.61 64% -15.62%
Silver_Parachute -6.49% 24.77 -0.29 8.81% -0.79 57% -15.48%
AssRS26 -10.68% 23.27 -0.58 11.69% -0.96 36% -15.01%
OptiMan 13.45% 25.02 0.42 0.60% 14.85 64% -14.91%


I'm a firm believer in quotes that Warren Buffet loves to proclaim to individual and professional investors alike:

Be fearful when others are greedy and greedy when others are fearful -- all of my research of the past twenty-five years is built on a conviction that this statement is true and applicable!

Rule No. 1 is never lose money. Rule No. 2 is never forget Rule No. 1! -- again, to think that avoiding a bear market is a waste of time flies in the face of this famous quote from Warren.
Post New | Post Reply | Report Post | Recommend It!
Print the post
Members reply directly to zeelotes here — and replies get answered. Reading is free; so is joining the conversation. Join Shrewd'm »
This community has written 6,227 posts about Mechanical Investing. The article-length ones it recommended most:
Dividend investing · 52 recs · 2025
Non-Mag7 screen · 34 recs · 2025
OT - Div yields and returns · 32 recs · 2024
Using AI to generate backtesting programs · 30 recs · 2025
Rankings for 19Dec2022 · 29 recs · 2022
Unthreaded | Threaded | Whole Thread (52) |


Announcements
Mechanical Investing FAQ
Contact Shrewd'm
Contact the developer of these message boards.

Best Of MI | Best Of | Favourites & Replies | All Boards | Followed Shrewds | Open Questions | Moving a community