Subject: Re: Watching Speech now
I have seem some laws that purport to prohibit any third party, like a union, negotiating pay and working conditions on behalf of an individual employee.

That eliminates management from offering benefits via third parties for employees. Insurance, for example, would be prohibited by an insurance company to employees because they ARE "negotiating pay AND working conditions" for each and every individual employee.

It would also violate the First Amendment (freedom of association) by all workers.